Page Yield Comparison Chart: Popular Inkjet Models |
| Printer: | HP Photosmart 6510 | Kodak Hero 7.1 | Epson Stylus NX625 | Brother MFC-J625DW |
| Number of Cartridges | Four | Two | Four | Four |
| Black Cartridge/Yield | Standard Capacity: HP 564 Black/250 pages High-Capacity: HP564XL Black/550 pages |
Standard Capacity: Black Ink Cartridge 10B/425 pages High-Capacity: Black Ink Cartridge 10XL/770 pages | Standard Capacity: Black T125120/220 pages High-Capacity: Black T127120/945 pages | Standard Capacity: Black LC71BK/300 pages High-Capacity: LC75BK/600 pages |
| Color Cartridge(s)/Yield | Standard Capacity: HP 564 Cyan, Magenta, and Yellow/300 pages each High-Capacity: HP564XL Cyan, Magenta, and Yellow /750 pages each |
Standard Capacity: Color Ink Cartridge 10C/420 pages (tri-color) High-Capacity: none | Standard Capacity: Cyan, Magenta, Yellow/320 pages each High-Capacity: Cyan, Magenta, Yellow/755 pages each | Standard Capacity: Black LC71 C,Y,M/300 pages each High-Capacity: LC75 C,Y,M/600 pages each |
| Cost Per Page, Black | Standard Capacity: $11.99/250 pages = 4.8 cents/page High-Capacity: $22.99/550 = 4.2 cents/page |
Standard Capacity: $12.99/425 pages = 3.1 cents/page High-Capacity: $19.99/770 = 2.6 cents/page | Standard Capacity: $15.49/220 pages = 7.0 cents/page High-Capacity: $29.49/945 pages = 3.1 cents/page | Standard Capacity: $14.99/300 pages = 5.0 cents/page High-Capacity: $24.99/600 pages = 4.2 cents/page |
| Cost Per Page, Color | Standard Capacity: $9.99/300 pages = 3.3 cents/page High-Capacity: $17.99/750 = 2.3 cents/page |
Standard Capacity: $19.99/420 pages = 4.8 cents/page High-Capacity: N/A | Standard Capacity: $12.69/320 pages = 4.0 cents/page High-Capacity: $20.39/755 pages = 2.7 cents/page | Standard Capacity: $9.99/300 pages = 3.3 cents/page High-Capacity: $14.99/600 pages = 2.5 cents/page |
| Printer: | HP Officejet Pro 8600 Premium eAIO | Lexmark OfficeEdge Pro 5500 | Epson Workforce Pro WP-4540 | Brother MFC-J6910DW |
| Number of Cartridges | Four | Four | Four | Four |
| Black Cartridge/Yield | Standard Capacity: HP 950 Black/1000 pages High-Capacity: HP950XL Black/2300 pages |
Standard Capacity: Black Ink Cartridge 200/625 pages High-Capacity: Black Ink Cartridge 200XL/2500 pages | Standard Capacity: Black (none) High-Capacity: Black T676XL/2400 pages | High Capacity: Black LC75BK/600 pages Super High Capacity: LC79BK/2400 pages |
| Color Cartridge(s)/Yield | Standard Capacity: HP 951 Cyan, Magenta, and Yellow/700 pages each High-Capacity: HP 951XL Cyan, Magenta, and Yellow /1500 pages each |
Standard Capacity: Color Ink Cartridge 200/520 pages each High-Capacity: 200XL Cyan, Magenta, Yellow/1600 pages each | Standard Capacity: none High-Capacity: Cyan, Magenta, Yellow/1200 pages each | Standard Capacity: Black LC75 C,Y,M/600 pages each High-Capacity: LC79 C,Y,M/1200 pages each |
| Cost Per Page, Black | Standard Capacity: $26.99/1000 pages = 2.7 cents/page High-Capacity: $36.99/2300 = 1.6 cents/page |
Standard Capacity: $25.99/625 pages = 4.2 cents/page High-Capacity: $36.99/2500 = 1.5 cents/page | Standard Capacity: none High-Capacity: $38.49/2400 pages = 1.6 cents/page | Standard Capacity: $24.99/600 pages = 4.2 cents/page High-Capacity: $39.99/2400 pages = 1.7 cents/page |
| Cost Per Page, Color | Standard Capacity: $19.99/700 pages = 2.9 cents/page High-Capacity: $27.99/1500 pages= 1.9 cents/page |
Standard Capacity: $21.99/500 pages = 4.4 cents/page High-Capacity: $33.99/1600 pages = 2.1 cents/page | Standard Capacity: none High-Capacity: $24.49/1200 pages = 2.0 cents/page | Standard Capacity: $14.99/600 pages = 2.5 cents/page High-Capacity: $22.99/1200 pages = 1.9 cents/page |
In the lower end models for home and home office use, as far as the black cartridge goes, Kodak did have the lowest cost overall for both with costs of 3.1 cents and 2.6 cents for standard and high capacity, respectively. With color printing, Kodak’s cost was not only higher per page than anyone else’s, but Brother, HP, and Epson printers all feature single-color ink tanks. HP had the lowest overall cost at 3.3 cents for standard capacity cartridge and 2.3 cents for high-capacity.
For the business-oriented models all of the OEMs, HP, Lexmark, Epson, and Brother all have high-capacity cartridges which rival lasers models in cost per page. In fact, for Epson, they don’t offer anything else except those cartridges (aside from the starter ones). Among the standard capacity cartridges for black, HP was the clear winner again, with Epson being the best value for high-capacity. For color ink, Brother had the lowest cost at 2.5 cents, however, their cartridge yields 100 less pages than the next closest competitor, HP (2.9 cents). Brother and HP were tied for the lowest cost per page at 1.9 cents for each of their colors, but this time the difference in yield was substantial—approx. 300 pages—when compared to HP’s.
BY ADAM HAIGH, Editor